Democratic Party Faces Scrutiny During Prolonged Government Shutdown

Writing in The Hill, Peek blamed the shutdown squarely on Schumer, noting that it “highlights three weaknesses undermining the Democratic Party as we head toward next year’s midterm elections.”

For one, she notes, Democratic Party leadership continues to face pressure from its progressive wing, which has gained significant influence over the party’s agenda. Schumer is reportedly wary of a potential primary challenge from New York Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, a dynamic that observers say may be shaping some of his recent political decisions.

“Second, President Trump has pushed Democrats to burrow into their far-left rabbit holes by occupying the all-powerful center,” Peek added. “Third, Democrats are pushing endlessly to spend more money; voters think that’s a mistake.”

Schumer is facing renewed pressure from within his party following backlash over his decision earlier this year to work with Republicans to avert a government shutdown. The move angered many Democrats, who accused him of conceding too much in negotiations, she says.

In the weeks that followed, some progressive activists and lawmakers called for Ocasio-Cortez (D-N.Y.) to mount a primary challenge against Schumer in the 2028 Senate race, Peek noted.

Polling from the left-leaning firm Data for Progress conducted after the March spending vote indicated growing dissatisfaction among Democratic voters. The survey found that Schumer had the lowest favorability rating among prominent New York Democrats and that he trailed Ocasio-Cortez by 19 points in a hypothetical primary matchup, the conservative analyst went on

Once known for his opposition to government shutdowns, Schumer now appears to be taking a more hardline stance, a shift that some political analysts attribute to pressure from his party’s progressive wing, she noted, adding:

Schumer is not the only moderate Democrat looking over his shoulder. In an August interview with Fox News, former House Speaker Kevin McCarthy (R-Calif.) said, “The only Democrats out there that are resonating and getting money are the socialists.”

He is right. All of the funding, excitement and energy in the Democratic Party is behind progressives. That may work in New York or other deep-blue states, but it’s unlikely to work in swing states like Pennsylvania or Ohio.

Right now, it isn’t even working in Minneapolis, where democratic socialist candidate Omar Fateh is trying to oust incumbent Democratic Mayor Jacob Frey. In a major slap in the face, the Democratic-Farmer-Labor Party, the official Democrat organization in Minnesota, rescinded the city party endorsement of Fateh.

As in New York, it is the young, urban voter driving the leftward push. Minnesota went for Kamala Harris last November by only 4 points, even though her running mate, Tim Walz, is governor of the state. Currently, polls show Fateh trailing Frey by about 13 points.

Young voters have emerged as a key source of support for Democratic Socialist candidate Zohran Mamdani, who is leading the race for mayor in heavily Democratic New York City. Mamdani’s message — focused on “unrealistic promises to make life more affordable,” as well as opposition to Israel’s policies, has resonated strongly with progressive voters, Peek noted.

Polling shows Mamdani ahead of former Governor Andrew Cuomo in the Democratic primary. Campaign finance filings indicate he has raised substantially more money than Cuomo, bolstered by contributions from major donors including philanthropist Elizabeth Simons, daughter of hedge fund founder James Simons, and by groups connected to organizations linked to left-wing financier George Soros.

“Democrats’ leftward lunge may have endeared the party to progressive billionaires, but it’s unlikely to improve the party’s image or win back the White House in 2028. Progressives are notoriously anti-police and anti-ICE; they favor open borders and extending benefits to non-citizens,” writes Peek.

“That is not where the country is.”